On simplicial commutative algebras with finite Andre-Quillen homology by James M. Turner L. Avramov, following D. Quillen, posed a conjecture to the effect that if $R \to A$ is a homomorphism of Noetherian rings then the Andr\'e-Quillen homology on the category of A-modules satisfies: $D_{s}(A|R;-) = 0$ for $s\gg 0$ implies $D_{s}(A|R;-) = 0$ for s>2. In an earlier paper, the author posed an extended version of this conjecture which considered A to be a simplicial commutative R-algebra with Noetherian homotopy such that the characteristic of $\pi_{0}A$ is non-zero. In addition, a homotopy characterization of such algebras was described. The main goal of this paper is to develop a strategy for establishing this extended conjecture and provide a complete proof when R is Cohen-Macaulay of characteristic 2. Note: this paper replaces "Nilpotency in the homotopy of simplicial commutative algebras".